Seit 2019: Rechtsanwalt bei Höcker 2012 - 2018: Präsident des Bundesverfassungsschutzes 1991 - 2012: Bundesministerium des Innern, Bonn und Berlin The interviewer uses it to highlight the binary of justice and law. From 1 August 2012 to 8 November 2018, he served as the President of the Federal Office for the Protection of the Constitution, Germany's domestic security agency and one of three agencies in the German Intelligence Community. Yet if political life in Chancellor Merkel’s Germany has in fact inherited even just some of the flavor of the East German Communist past, then Maaßen is not wrong in declaring that there is something “totalitarian” in what is going on in what has been dubbed the “Berlin Republic.”, Objective data from public opinion polls support Maaßen and Meinhardt in their claims of a repressive political culture. Renate Koch of the Allensbach Institute reported on a study concerning free speech in Germany, writing in the Frankfurter Allgemeine in 2019: “The population views freedom of opinion as one of the most important guarantees of the German constitution. In the wake of the opening of the Berlin Wall and the collapse of the Soviet Union, it appeared that liberal democracy was on an inexorable victory march around the world. Renate Köcher, “Grenzen der Freiheit,” Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung, May 23, 2019. AERTEC Solutions is exporting digitalisation technology to Poland. It is a matter of a long-term process of erosion that cannot be repaired with a single political act, as some may wish. 3. Bärbel Bohley’s[3] disappointed phrase is well known: “We wanted justice, but all we got is the rule of law.” Isn’t morality the better and ethically higher good? Maaßen: Yes, it is, because if she had known it, she would have drawn the border tighter, out of fear of crossing it. Freedom House and others have copiously documented how the wave of freedom is being rolled back.[2]. Hans-Georg Maaßen. So this situation has resulted from a failure of the moderates who have surrendered to left-wing narratives rather than engaging in rational debate, with arguments, facts, and parity—how can this be overcome? The following essay comments on the interview with Hans-Georg Maaßen[1] conducted by Moritz Schwarz and published in Junge Freiheit on August 14, 2020. And beyond that limit, everyone can do what they want, without fearing punishment. Interview with Bart Biebuyck, FCH JU. For example, when the CSU [Christian Social Union] declares the AfD to be made of up of “enemies of Bavaria,” or when government funds flow to the partially terrorist Antifa, or when the federal government, the media, and public institutions officially finance the “fight against the right.”. Perhaps one should have paid more attention in 1989, which not only witnessed the November celebration in Berlin but also the bloody June in Beijing, where the democracy movement at Tiananmen was murdered by the Communist Party and its tanks. But that is exactly the formulation of Article 16A of the Basic Law—so now even quotations from the Basic Law are being stigmatized as “right-wing populist.” The exclusion of opinions that accord with the law is inconsistent with democratic debate. An Interview With Morgan Maassen August 31, 2010 By SURFER Social icon website Social icon rss Social icon twitter. This transcript was prepared by a lawyer, whom the Club of Clear … The legacy of the Merkel era may well be an ironclad unanimity in building a wall against the right, a “popular front” politics, instead of a principled defense of liberal democracy, against the extremism of right and left. Instead it will require a fundamental democratic healing process and some long democratic patience. However, when despotism goes too far, there is a popular mandate to rebel in order to regain liberty, which is a human right. Maven is a project management and comprehension tool. A Tyranny of Values: “It Is Somehow Totalitarian”: Interview with Hans-Georg Maaßen, Matthias Küntzel on the Iran Deal and Germany, Telos in the News: Pandemic Responses and the Risk of Dictatorship, Telos 194 (Spring 2021): Political Theology Today, The Telos Press Podcast: F. Cartwright Weiland on the Commission on Unalienable Rights, The Indian Farmers’ Movement 2020–21: Part III: Writing the Alphabet of Democratic Hope. So, freedom is the space that emerges when morality is minimized? Hans-Georg Maaßen (born 24 November 1962) is a German civil servant and lawyer. Maaßen: No. 18 December, 2020. By now, there are no longer genuine conservatives in the media and the institutions. 27 July, 2020. McIntyre Library. Maaßen: No, on the contrary, that is exactly the totalitarian aspect. It is true that the law only provides a moral minimum. The name derives from the late seventeenth or early eighteenth century and may refer to African residents. Yet “unwritten laws” are not really laws at all, and they certainly do not have the democratic legitimacy that adheres to a law promulgated by a duly elected government. Maaßen is not alone in his claims. Hans-Georg Maaßen. Another Interview with Morgan Maassen October 21st, 2020 | Words by Bryson Smith | Photos by Morgan Maassen. Even Russia seemed briefly to be lurching toward modern governance structures, and the Central Asian states, the “stans,” claimed their own sovereignty (if only, often as not, to revert to indigenous forms of authoritarianism). In August 2020 the city officially renamed the street Anton-Wilhelm-Arno-Straße, after the first African to receive a doctorate in Germany (Wittenberg, 1734), who went on to teach at universities of Jena and Halle but left Germany to return to Africa, today’s Ghana, in 1747. The age of Latin American dictatorships belonged to the past, certainly in the southern cone and in Brazil, although not in Venezuela and Cuba. If she did not know that, then this is not really an example of proleptic self-censorship. Welcome to the world as seen by Morgan Maassen. Maaßen: The political parties do not play the exclusively decisive role. Translated by Russell A. Berman, who has written a separate note here. Furthermore, it is supposed to monitor people and groups who pursue that goal of overthrowing the state, but not to oversee “tendencies” in the society. An English translation of the interview appears here. If there is something totalitarian going on in our society, shouldn’t the Domestic Intelligence Service (a federal agency comparable to the intelligence branch of FBI—trans.) When we think about e-commerce in the upcoming year and years the following four points should be on our radar. First because a moralistic system of prohibitions is imposed on the legal system, thereby restricting the guaranteed freedoms. So far you have given no example—except the moor—to show that your analysis describes our reality. Interview with Anna Maaßen, EACP. So we are no longer a liberal society but already totalitarian? This extrapolation may seem counterintuitive, for one might assume that values-driven activists act only out of the best of intentions, whether their morality is utilitarian, pursuing the greatest good, or deontological in upholding irrevocable principles. Thilo Sarrazin (born 1945), former Senator for Finance in Berlin and member of the Executive Board of the Bundesbank, presented a critical account of immigration policies in his 2010 book Deutschland schafft sich ab (Germany abolishes itself), which was attacked for alleged racism and xenophobia, although Sarrazin also found prominent defenders. Maaßen: We have to differentiate. 3. See “Mohrenstrasse: Berlin Farce over Renaming of ‘Racist’ Station,” BBC News, July 9, 2020. A morally grounded act against positive law is only a last resort, not to be taken casually, and only in the face of dire circumstances and the threat of tyranny. Yet one can also doubt the ulterior motivations of the moralists, who may be neither Millian nor Kantian but instead Nietzschean, vigorously pursuing a will to power. Seit 2019: Rechtsanwalt bei Höcker 2012 - 2018: Präsident des Bundesverfassungsschutzes 1991 - 2012: Bundesministerium des Innern, Bonn und Berlin Hans-Georg Maaßen (born 1962) served as president of Germany’s Office for the Protection of the Constitution, der Verfassungsschutz, from 2012 to 2018. He was a member of the SPD since 1973, but he was expelled for his views in 2020. What we are experiencing is the result of a chronic development that has been underway for decades. Conservative groups, notably the Junge Union, the youth affiliate of the CDU, have protested against engaging a former Stasi informant for the surveillance of free speech. Yet it also resonates with deeper, much older, pre-democratic traditions in Germany, the escape into cultural interiority as a flight from public life. But so far they are not doing this sufficiently, which brings us back to the beginning of our problem. 2. Dr. Maaßen, the Mayor of Tübingen, Boris Palmer,[1] has warned against a “world of prohibitions” in Germany, in which “moral condemnation” could follow the smallest mistake. 4. Boris Palmer (born 1972), Mayor of the City of Tübingen, is a member of the Green Party, in which he occupies a relatively conservative position, especially on the topic of immigration, as evidenced by the title of his 2017 book, We Can’t Help Everyone. Maaßen writes in the somewhat different context of Germany. That Arab Spring of hope gave way to a new winter in the Middle East and not only there. The spiral grows ever tighter. Nearly two-thirds are convinced that one has to ‘be very careful concerning the topics one addresses’ because there are many unwritten laws concerning which opinions are acceptable and permissible.”[4]. Nonetheless, individuals retain the freedom to choose to obey a higher law—but they should not face bullying or political compulsion to do so. [5] It is true that we have faced some startlingly illiberal treatment inside the CDU—for example, when some of our friends in the party publicly call us a “cancerous growth.” Or when the media—rather than critically questioning government policies—shield it from criticism by discrediting critics and defaming them. I am deeply concerned that our legal state—the rule of law—is being more and more undermined by the rule of morality. On 19.9.2020, the interview was made available to the international public on YouTube. When we judge the tyrannical moralists among us, we should not think of them as good-hearted saints but as iterations of Dostoevsky’s Grand Inquisitor. By subverting democratic legitimacy, the primacy of values paves the way to genuine political tyranny, not only to moral tyranny. Maaßen has presented the episode as an effort by the left wing of the SPD to generate a political crisis within the governing coalition of SPD and CDU/CSU. Her statement here gave expression to disappointment with the experience of the unification, its economic consequences, and the emerging political structures in unified Germany. However, it is a different matter altogether if this occurs at the workplace, where it quickly becomes a matter of so-called “mobbing”—and employees have legal protections against that because ostracism on the job may impact one’s fundamental rights. 4 min read. But these tendencies do not just appear out of nothing; they are carried out by people and groups. Globalization and neoliberalism had not only failed to bring human rights to China; they also generated economic inequality and displacements in the countries of the developed world with attendant social and political disruptions. Such hypermoralism in the service of the conquest of political power is playing out in the United States with the current protest movement, including the street-level violence, serving as a mobilization effort in the presidential campaign. But sanctions in the case of transgressions typically do not touch on basic rights. Interview with Morgan Maassen: Surf Photographer Turning Reality into Dreams Chantae September 17, 2015 As the son of a sea urchin diver, salt water has always been a part of Morgan’s blood. This is not the case because of the primacy of the freedom of opinion that also protects extremist positions, up to a point. By now they decide who is permissible and with which themes. Anti-racist and postcolonial activists have viewed the street name as demeaning and have agitated against it. The Soviet satellite states threw off their Communist shackles, and the occupied Baltics regained their independence. “Mohrenstrasse: Berlin Farce over Renaming of ‘Racist’ Station,”, Moral Tyranny in Germany Today: Comments on the Interview with Hans-Georg Maaßen, Corona, the Public Sphere, and the Credibility Crisis: A Note on Arnold Vaatz, Matthias Küntzel on the Iran Deal and Germany, Telos in the News: Pandemic Responses and the Risk of Dictatorship, Telos 194 (Spring 2021): Political Theology Today, The Telos Press Podcast: F. Cartwright Weiland on the Commission on Unalienable Rights, The Indian Farmers’ Movement 2020–21: Part III: Writing the Alphabet of Democratic Hope. Maaßen: It displaces the liberty. What can be done against these developments? As I said, in the context of a liberal rule of law, it is the law that defines the limits of permissible speech, which is grounded in our Basic Law as freedom of opinion. Stormy sessions in the tropics. We don’t have the power to demand another debate. As Communism becomes acceptable—despite the experience of East Germany—the strategy of moral tyranny makes sure that symmetrical openings to the right are prohibited. But our liberty does not depend on the one word “moor.”. 21K likes. In Maaßen’s words, “it is somehow totalitarian.”. Maaßen: Not at all, especially because “totalitarian” is not an issue for the Domestic Intelligence Service. And is it not held up by the American press as an example that others, including the United States, should emulate? There is certainly a relevant dimension of higher morality, but it is not the role of the state to mandate that individuals act according to it. Babbu Maan Interview on Farmers Protest: Farmers protesting at Delhi borders are getting immense support from the Punjabi singers and other prominent celebrities across the nation. Maassen is the man behind Bogus Blog and the winner of this year’s $5,000 Flame Grant from the Follow the Light … PLoS ONE 15(5): e0233107 . 2. I am talking about debate, not our democracy in general. Similarly, in society at large there are some traditional, unwritten soft social norms, such as greetings or how one dresses for particular circumstances. For if the electorate cannot discuss a topic freely, what is the democratic legitimacy of decisions taken by the government? University of Wisconsin – Eau Claire. Jefferson understands human nature: People will put up with a lot, and in the interest of an orderly society with “the forms to which they are accustomed,” this behavioral inertia is preferable to some mercurial instability. Maaßen: It is indisputable that all not-left positions are being systematically marginalized. Hans-Georg Maaßen:[2] I am a jurist, out of passion, and that’s why I am frightened to have to agree with him in part. Video Interview 37 minutes Weather, Food, and More: The Truth About Triggers Vince Martin, MD. But when a long train of abuses and usurpations, pursuing invariably the same Object evinces a design to reduce them under absolute Despotism, it is their right, it is their duty, to throw off such Government, and to provide new Guards for their future security. … Associate Professor of Pharmacology Erasmus MC, Netherlands. Subsequent to this, the social-democratic members of the current grand coalition government called for Maassen’s dismissal. Maaßen: Yes: first because the law determines the limit that everyone accepts as a minimum. [4] But as a result of the current discussion about racism, people avoid the term because they do not want to be labeled racists. It is worrisome for the character of German democracy if more than two-thirds of the citizens believe that they can only participate in public debate with restrictions. We have to be frank about how the liberal democracies too have become incubators of illiberal tendencies. Wednesday, August 26, 2020 The following interview was conducted by Moritz Schwarz and appeared in Junge Freiheit, on August 14, 2020. Yet that is precisely the precondition of freedom. Interview Notes. Isn’t that right? group. 10 June, 2020. Humans are of course social beings, which makes shunning a particularly harmful punishment—whether others engage in the avoidance voluntarily or out of fear of facing ostracism themselves. Craig-Atkins E, Jervis B, Cramp L, Hammann S, Nederbragt AJ, Nicholson E, et al. UHC 298. The fear of saying something “wrong” leads to people becoming even more circumspect than morality demands. Furthermore, Allensbach documents an enormous gap between public and private speech: “In general, the public sphere is associated with much less freedom of opinion than the private sphere. Watch Video … But is that really happening here or are you just claiming it? As I said, it’s a matter of institutions across society that have willingly fallen in line, including the churches. He writes of an extensive “repression of doubt,” and he sees elements of East German opinion management reappearing in unified Germany, which is sometimes only a “simulacrum of democracy” and the Bundestag only “a version of the People’s Chamber,” the pseudo-legislature of the GDR (communist East Germany). In other words, they feel that they have to hold their tongue on the primary domestic political issue since Merkel’s decision to open the borders in September 2015: that is surely a “structural transformation of the public sphere,” to use philosopher Jürgen Habermas’s famous term. sound the alarm? Within Europe, the tension is played out inside the EU when Poland and Hungary are pilloried for their alleged misbehavior. Maaßen’s identification of the problem of compulsory morality as a threat to the democratic rule of law in fact points toward an even more troubling dynamic. Interview with Montserrat Barriga, ERA. 53, 91. Automation for the safe flight termination of RPAS. It is … Our website uses cookies to enhance your experience and show you more relevant content. Subjects. Latest Headlines Emergency Go Fund Me for … This is why the interview with Hans-Georg Maaßen is important. Eau Claire, WI. Fixing those problems is a duty of society, i.e., the public, parties, media, institutions, etc. These two different relationships to democratic origins likely inform different political cultures, East and West, including different attitudes toward restrictions on political speech and toward by fiat decisions by the chancellor. I do my part, as is known, by participating in the Values Union. Maassen, Adolph Hones, Kenneth W., 1898-1972 …
Nonverbale Kommunikation Mit Behinderten Menschen,
Eisdiele Westend Frankfurt,
Projektmanagement Excel Vorlage,
S Pen Note 9 Bluetooth,
Bei Dieser Gelegenheit,
Arbeitsblätter Anatomie Altenpflege,
Verbandsgemeinde Trier-land Personalausweis,